But I absolutely appreciate his delivery. When I opened Romania, I discovered several things:
An extra set of tiles to correct some misprinted tiles on the main boards. (In fact all the main tiles were perfectly playable, but two were noticeably off center and two has their reference numbers wrong).
Some stickers to cover incorrect charts in the rulebook.
An extra page of rules (two sections that had been added , or inadvertently left out of the main rules).
Another small packed of Errata for 18 Espana.
Now … yes, ideally all those things should have been caught earlier. But the fact is that instead of just shipping the games with errors and adding rules files to BGG, Lonny ate the cost and made it right.
Also, The priority deal marker was a nice wooden bat (like a batarang) instead of a simple “Priority deal” card.1
Yes, 18xx is a small niche, but it’s always nice to see game companies trying to do right by their customers.
I’d actually seen it in the game I used, but the owner of that game routinely adds some appropriate sculpture or woodworking item to the game, so I’d thought it was custom. ︎
My typical rule on new games is “wait a year and see if they are still getting played,” but I did try a few games that friends thought I might like.
Loop 40 (3 plays) — A Scout-like shedding game where you only play runs (or single cards), and the cards loop around …. if the 28 is led to a trick, 28 is the lowest card and 27 is the highest (and 40+1 is a valid run). When you win a trick you shed the final cards played, but get all the lower cards. Loop 40 is one of those games where I’m not sure how I feel, but I’m intrigued. There are definitely levels to the game, although (like any card game) you can get a bad hand. Probably the game that generated the most discussion, even if not the best game. Suggest, at least until I can figure out if it’s flaws outweigh its interest. (The chief flaw is that you can be forced to pass for most if not all of a hand, which is boring).
Jungo — A fatally flawed Scout-like shedding game with no all the negatives of Loop 40 (and then some) and no positives. Avoid.
Greylune — I never played Spyrium, but a William Attia worker placement game is worth trying. The hooks are two fold. 1) You deal out cards in a grid and place workers between them, and the workers can activate either card, paying more for each other worker touching that card (or not activating but gaining gold equal to each other worker touching that card). This alleviates some of the problems of going last … yes, you will get worse spots, but you’ll pay less. 2) There are three phases and you only place workers in phase A, but when you pass and go to phase B you get to activate them, so there’s a much more interesting tempo management game. Only played once, but I would have played it again (tried to, but there was only 1-2 copies). Will probably buy it. Suggest
Elements of Truth (2 plays) — A Wits and Wagers-esque game of science questions such as “Which is older, Sharks or Saturns Rings.” The twist is that you have chits of 1-10 and can only use each chip once, so you want to use your big chits on questions you are more confident of. By the Veritasium youtube channel. I’d play this, but I don’t think it’s a game I’d suggest much, so Indifferent-plus.
1953 Everest — So this week I learned that there’s a series of games called 19xx and they aren’t train related1. This is a resource management game about conquering Everest, and you stack your cards in a pyramid until you get a 4th level. We played wrong (missing a crucial setup phase that provided resources) but this seems like a solid, deep game in a small box. Hard to find in the US, but a European is buying several copies to send back. And yes, I bought one. Suggest.
Abraca-Who? — Kind of a reverse Love Letter where everyone but you knows your role, and you have to deduce it. Players can also duel each other, which provides information (and also bluffing). Much like Coup you can get into fully calculable endgames but they are fast. We had a rule or two wrong, but this works. Suggest.
Epochs: Course of Cultures — The latest Civ/Through-the-Ages wannabe (but has a map). This … wasn’t bad, had some good ideas, I’d play it again, but it’s Indifferent because its too long
Timespan — A different Civ/Through-the-Ages wannabe (but NO map). Faster than Epochs, but almost no interaction (apart from a few bonus VP to the player who finishes various VP tracks first). Again, not bad, some good ideas, I’d play it again, but Indifferent because of the heads-down-solitaire nature.
Greenwood — A worker placement/resource management: each player’s cards create the spaces that workers go on, and your workers go on your own cards … but each player has 1-2 spies that can only go on other player’s cards that already have a worker. It’s not bad, and if you love it replayability is through the roof because each faction in play adds a mechanism to the game. (Similar to how Stationfall changes rules with certain characters). I didn’t love it, but I didn’t hate it and I’d be willing to try a few more times and see. Indifferent.
Older Games Played for the First Time
Spokes — Abstracts aren’t my jam, but I have a soft spot for bicycle racing games and this was pretty good (despite being an abstract). The map is a mix of sticks arranged on a track (A picture makes this clear) and each player has a rondel of spokes. On your turn, move around our personal rondel, swap the color for one on the board and then move as far as you can with one color. If you draft somone you get a token to ignore one color on the map. Quite clever, brilliant design, still only Indifferent from me because I don’t like Abstracts, but if you do check it out.
1880: Romania — I played 1880: China a few years ago and wasn’t sure how I felt, so I was happy to try this new variant. I like it and snagged a copy (as a few were on sale due to a shipping snafu), partially because this also 2p and 3p variants, so I can likely play with the TaoLing. Suggest.
18NYC: The Great American Subway — Should 18xx games have random events? I do not think so. But if they do they should not be nearly this fiddly. (There was a lot of time spent looking for rules, and we just handwaved and made a ruling in several cases). I found this interesting to play once2, but I’m done. Avoid.
High Frontier 4 All Module 5 — When I say that I’d be happy never playing M5 again (barring a huge variant re-write), that’s very close to the most positive review of those who played. This turns a space exploration game into a game about protecting your leadership position in companies. I love stock games (I played 18xx for 1.5 out of my 4 days at the con, after all) and boardroom shenanigan games, but that’s not what I want in HF4A. Avoid Module 5 but still Enthusiastic for Base game and Modules 0124.
Prior to my Swiss Game (and multiple Double Pushing Finesses), I played a few sessions of the local sectional. This was the North American Open Pairs weekend. I played in the NAOPs in 2024, but didn’t play any of the qualifier games this time, so I just played in the sectional. When talking with Sam Dinkin (who had a new Junior International Player taking a gap year before college as partner) I wished him luck in the upcoming game and he said “I look forward to the NAOP, because when I lose there I know it’s probably my fault.”
Ah, the iniquities of having novice or intermediate players deliver a terrible result to you and often not even knowing that it happened. It’s a rite of passage, and a source of good stories. When I first came back to playing Bridge in San Antonio (a few years after moving back) I remember messing up the play of a suit against Diane Olsen (who has since passed … we named this weekend’s tournament after her) and having no recourse but to play for a miracle position, which happened. (I was good enough to shrug and say “Sorry”)
It’s “Getting Fixed,” (but sometimes experts do that to you as well). More specifically “Getting LOLed,” (Little-Old-Ladied). Hunted by the Rabbit. I mean, we like to complain about it, but it’s part of the game and the best stories. God protects children, fools, and ships named Enterprise and we’ve all witnessed it.
But sometimes it really pours down.
One session, my partner and I are having a nice game. We correctly bid a slam that the field mostly missed (which I’ve written up, but am waiting to publish), to the chagrin of the experts watching us do it. We have a few small mistakes, but ones that cost “A matchpoint or two” not whole boards.
And then we play against two novices, specifically two ladies who are diminutive and well aged. It’s brutal.
My RHO opens 1NT. LHO transfers to Spades. Partner bids 2NT (“Pick a minor”). RHO bids 4 Spades. What, she’s not captain! Has she not read my basic bidding articles?1 When Dummy Hits with QJxxx of spades and out partner and I both relax as justice will no doubt be served. Nope. The 1NT bidder had a 20 count and two finesses worked.
Next hand the auction by the opponents is 1NT-2C (stayman); 2NT. The second impossible auction on two boards2. Instead of playing in two of a minor for 90 or 110 points, they are in 2NT for a higher score.
Mercifully the third hand is ours to bid and play. Average.
Next we go up against another novice pair, but for variety’s sake they are a young couple (younger than me! a rarity in the Bridge World).
Their auction is simple — 1 Heart – 3 No Trump. When Dummy (the wife? girlfriend?) puts her hand down husband says “You have a 6th Heart, you should rebid hearts!”3 But in fact No Trump takes the same amount of tricks so instead of getting an average (if she’d rebid hearts) we get a near-bottom.
I open a bare minimum. Husband/Boyfriend overcalls. Partner makes a game try. I’ reject as vehemently as possible. Girlfriend decides to compete and gets doubled. I’m about to reject when girlfriend competes. Partner doubles this and we get +500. Feels good, but it turns out our 23 HCP game makes and without the competition we get +620. In some senses this isn’t on the novices … I would have rejected the game try. But the fact is that most of the time when you get +500 in a situation like this (you weren’t going to be in game, you get 200+ points after doubling, which is better than any part score you could hope for) it feels bad. You think “We got 500 instead of 140 or so” but then discover “No, you had 620 available.”
Again the 3rd board is mercifully routine.
So that’s it. Average game. Get home and looking at the emailed results and it’s a 60%! I confirm that in those two rounds were scored well below average. (That first round was 23% across 3 boards!), which means our first 21 boards were averaging something like 70%! A monster game, and neither my partner and I had considered it much of anything special. (We were both shocked at our score when we discussed it next day).
And the answer is, as always, inattention bias. We’re focused on our own mistakes (so as to improve).
I expect Novice and Intermediates (and even sometimes experts) to make mistakes that give me gifts. I remember the one or two boards where I did something clever and earned a top. I will point out when I think partner has misbid or misplayed (mainly with an eye towards improving our score) and partner does the same.
I vaguely notice whenever the opponents misplay and give me a bonus trick or two (except the real howlers), which are injustices …. against the people who played against strong pairs. Looking back on the scores I find a bunch of injustices … in my favor.
Declarer misplays to miss an overtrick. Lots of players missed it, but I was lucky not to be against an expert.
A missed close game.
Another missed game. Not even close.
Another missed overtrick.
Opponents in the wrong game.
Opponents let me play and make a partscore when they a) should defeat me and b) be in their own partscore, easily making.
Declarer went down in a cold game.
Opponent passes a hand I’d open every day (its only 11 HCP, but A+A+K and good shape). I’m in passout seat I (correctly) throw the hand in (because I have a borderline hand and no major suit). Passed out when they can make three of a major.
They miss a pretty easy slam (-480).
That’s almost half the other hands! And ~five of the remaining hands were literally “One side has two or three tricks that can’t go away.” Nigh impossible to mis defend or misplay (assuming they are bid correctly). (“Rabbit proof,” as Mollo says).
So … perhaps those two rounds were justice, righting earlier iniquities. Who knows?
Update — I just noticed the announcement that The Bridge World is back in business (online) after closing down earlier this year.
Thanks to Eric Brosius for suggesting putting them in one place as a geeklist. ︎
Of course you can have a convention that makes it possible or reasonable, but if you did that you wouldn’t be a little old lady. ︎
Stories like this are why my wife never played Bridge. The husband is correct (in this case) and public discussions and arguments are routine, but they are often a bit more pointed and electric between couples. ︎
Played in a Swiss Team game today, which is the first time I’ve played IMPs (instead of matchpoints) in roughly a year.
In the first round we are randomly paired against an OK intermediate team, so we are just brutalizing them when I pick up the final board of the match.
S: x H: AKQxxx D: AK9x C: xx
This is an easy 1 Heart opening. I think I might just Jump Shift and force to game if partner makes a response.
Partner bids 2 NT the “Jacoby 2NT” showing … a strong, game forcing heart raise (typically with 4 card support). Wild! We are almost certainly making a small slam, and a grand is certainly possible. I bid 3 Spades, which shows shortness, mainly because that means that partner’s natural bid will show (or deny) a club stopper. It’s just possible we are off two fast club tricks. Partner bids 4 Clubs and now it’s time to decide between small and grand slam. I bid 4NT (Roman Key Card) and partner bids 5 Hearts, showing both missing aces (and denying the heart queen, but I knew that).
I make a slight misbid of 5NT … 5 Spades is the correct bid to say “We have all the aces & trump honors, where are your extra kings?”), but this partnership is somewhat shaky on followups to RKC. The important thing is that this shows all the key cards, my aces and the king and queen of trump, so partner can either show a king or bid grand with multiple kings (or if she can count to 13, which might be hard since she doesn’t know about my 6th heart).
Partner bids 6 Hearts, denying the club king. Because I’ve misbid, she could still have the spade king … there was no space to show it.
Is it possible to be missing both kings? AQx of spades and AQx of clubs, I guess. I really want to bid the grand. But there is also a chance that partner has three small diamonds. I look over at the other table and the players sitting my way. They are never bidding the grand. They might even miss the slam, although that seems unlikely. We’re blitzing them, making a grand is just rubbing it in.
I pass six hearts.
The lead is a club and I see that I was right to think partner was a bit shaky, as she tables S: Axx H: xxx D: Jxx C: AKxx
Not only is the club king there, the fourth heart is gone. To be fair, it’s a tough hand in our system. 1N is only semi-forcing and our limit raise is natural (and passable). Still it seems like she could have bid 2 Clubs game forcing, then jumped to game in hearts to show a minimum. I mean, I’d still be here, so no harm no foul.
I play the ace of clubs and RHO plays a spade. Huh?
LHO has seven clubs, RHO has none and RHO also doesn’t trump? I roll to disbelieve and make easily.
Everyone asks “No clubs?” and RHO reveals one. I play the heart from dummy and RHO plays the spade from last trick and (after multiple asks) confirms “No hearts.”
“I was really hoping you’d bid the grand,” LHO admits. I have a heart loser.
And after all this agonizing about the grand, I might not make. I have to decide how to play the diamonds.
I decide against the natural play of trying to drop the queen doubleton and instead lead the Diamond Jack. The basic idea is to play RHO for QTx(x) of diamonds. A “pushing finesse” is when you lead a high card intending to float it1. In this case, if it’s covered, then I will win and then finesse for the next lower spot. A priori this is only 25% … you need one opponent to have two cards. (Technically 24% because of vacant spaces). But … with LHO having four hearts I think it’s reasonable to play RHO for QTx(x) of diamonds.
This also works if RHO has Qxxx and LHO has the stiff ten. In theory I could also win if RHO has Qxx and LHO has Tx, but then after the first pushing finesse I’ll have to cash my other higher diamond to drop the ten, which I’m not intending to do. And who knows, RHO might fail to cover. (They shouldn’t, but who knows?)
The finesse …. doesn’t work, but I confirm that LHO started with Qxx. So at least nothing worked.
On our comparison we average +7 Imps for seven hand (270-310 point swing) … and one push.
We lose the second match quickly. Multiple hands are claimed after a trick or two (“Well played”) and before we compare it seems flat-ish, although our opponents carefully went to five of a minor when three no seems attractive but fails. Our team-mates were in 3NT, not too surprising, but also missed another game. Oh well. For our 3rd match we get another intermediate team and things seem to be going well when I pick up S: Q542 H: 9xx D: AQJTx C: Q
LHO opens 1 Club and RHO bids 1 Heart. 2 Diamonds isn’t a great overcall … I’m likely to be on lead, and I’m really only overcalling because I want partner to lead a diamond. I don’t really have ten points, but a semi-solid suit is a semi-solid suit. On the other hand, if I lead a spade partner will know I don’t really love spades and want a diamond switch. It might be The Imp of the Perverse whispering in my ear, but I do it.
2 Diamonds.
LHO has a good hand a jumps to 4 Hearts and …. partner bids 5 Diamonds as the Imp nods his approval. (“Told you”) On this auction partner has maybe five diamonds, at most one heart. At Imps she could be bidding to make or sacrifice … the rule is “When in doubt bid one more.” RHO and I pass and LHO doubles, ending the auction.
LHO leads a diamond and both the Imp and I beam when dummy hits.
(Dummy) S: AT8 H: — D: K9xxx C:T97xx
(My Hand) S: Q542 H: 9xx D: AQJTx C: Q
I’m in the Bonus Round! (“The Best Sacrifices are those that Make.”) If I pick up spades for one loser, I make. I win the diamond queen in hand, ruff a heart and shoot out a club. May as well get the lay of the land. LHO wins and (after some thought) returns a heart. I ruff. When I lead another club RHO shows out.
Let’s take stock. LHO has five clubs, which means he must have exactly four hearts (if he had six clubs there is a chance he’d be 6-5, but 5-5 in the rounded suits opens 1 Heart). From his failure to lead a second diamond, I think he has one, so three spades exactly.
The easy way to play spades for one loser is to play RHO for Kxx. With ATx in dummy I could also play LHO for KJx. Another double-pushing finesse, although this one isn’t for no losers, but for one loser. Lead the queen (covered) and then cross back to hand and lead up towards the ten.
This is basically the exact same situation as before … except I’m missing the king and all the lower cards have been promoted one step. Before was AK9xx opposite Jxx, this is ATxx opposite Qxxx. Because I’m missing the king I have a guaranteed loser, but otherwise the same.
Well, there is one other difference. Dummy doesn’t have have A-T-small, it has A-T-8. That gives a 3rd option.
If LHO ducks smoothly on the second round I could also play him for K9x and insert the eight, forcing RHO’s jack. It will be hard for LHO to duck with the jack (What if I only have two spades?).
Given how strongly he bid, I think LHO probably has the King so I’m going to play him for having either KJx or K9x2. Let’s double check … Does that work with what I know from the bidding/play?
LHO probably has the heart ace (no heart lead). If I give him all that I think RHO would still always rebid 1 Heart with KQJxxx and out, maybe less3. I think this arrangement of high cards is reasonable on the auction. I don’t think it is reasonable for LHO to bid 4 Hearts on Jxx AQxx x AKJxx. That looks like a three heart bid. (If LHO had AKxx of hearts or KQxx of hearts, I suspect the lead would have been a heart, so AQxx is about as strong as he can have).
I play the queen of spades, covered by the king and win the ace. I cross back to hand by ruffing a club and lead a spade. LHO agonizes (giving away the show) then plays the Jack (from an original holding of KJx).
Five diamonds doubled making (with our team-mates making four hearts the other way) means we have a near blitz.
The rest of the day is solid. We lose another match, but blitz two more matches, albeit with no other double-pushing finesses. The two top teams played each other in the last round and so our blitz allows us to overtake the loser and snag second place. Overall this sectional has been pretty good to me, no wins but multiple second places (and a stronger than normal field because of people practicing for the North American Open Pairs).
I’ll take it.
Term from Eric Rodwell in “The Rodwell Files.” Double pushing finesse is my own coinage, unless I’ve Rodwell already coined it and I forgot. ︎
There’s also the possibility the LHO errs and doesn’t cover the spade queen, which may let me make with Kxx opposite J9x. ︎
RHO should probably have bid 5 hearts (since I’m assuming she started with six hearts) but that’s not my problem. But since she started with two diamonds, and isn’t used to IMPs, who knows. ︎
I have now played 1833NE four times: once in April (a 5p takeover game, using one of the old sets) and three times this month: A 3p non-takeover, takeover games of 5p and 3p.
Game Review Thoughts:
The non-takeover game has interest — the shifting interconnections are complex. I would be happy to play it again, particularly if time is short.
I don’t particularly like how the interconnection bonuses are presented on the map (in how some direct connections are not next to the indirect) and have printed out an extra page of the connections chart from the rules. Tabular form is fine for me. I may print out a few more copies for reference. In my last game I mostly just used that.
Our 5p Takeover game — my 3rd game, two players second ’33NE game (first with takeovers) and two players first ’33NE game — took < 4 hours with a laptop spreadsheet to run the final 4 ORs. (All were experienced 18xx). My 3p non-takeover game was ~ 2h45m (no laptop). The last game (3p Takeover) was 3h 20m including cleanup.
The chrome (ferries, shifting interconnections, map, companies) work well on the 1846 base (ability to issue/redeem shares, slow phasing train rush, pay for all track). ’46 has proven itself highly durable (I have over 60 face to face games, and a few dozen PBEM) and if ’33 NE doesn’t get nearly as many plays, partially that will be due to the fact that it is perhaps twice as long when playing takeovers, enough to make a weeknight game a touch inconvenient.
As in ’46, some charters have special rules for a company that are easy to miss … be sure to look at them on your first game. (In particular — the St Lawrence and Atlantic / Atlantic & St. Lawrence presidents get $100 when Portland and Montreal are connected).
Strategy Thoughts:
I’ve no idea how much the privates should go for … clearly the Ogdensburg RR promotes decent mid-game runs and can be worth a premium, and the D&H RR has great P/E ratio and power, albeit at the cost of bleeding your company for an extra $40.
Early on the Boston suburbs are where the money is …. the owner of the Champlain & St. Lawrence will likely start a company near Montreal but those are terrible first runs.
The $100 bonus for the A&StL/StL&A connection will entice someone. But you need to under invest in the northern company and buy into the Boston company(s) to not fall too far behind.
Also, the big connection bonuses in Phase III/IV are in Montreal/Portland/Boston so its not like ignoring the north can work it. It depends on when the train rush pauses (and I now realize that different regions of the board have different interests in the train rush, and that will affect the game).
Looking at the map, I think the St Lawrence & Atlantic’s best bet is to ignore the Champlain tracks and drive east to Richmond/Sherbrooke in OR1.2. With the automatic token in Sherbrooke it can run a ‘2’ and a ‘2+2’ for $12/share (or two ‘2’ trains for $10), which admittedly isn’t great; but it’s also halfway to the $100 bonus (to the president) and the Montreal to Portland run, which could be connected before SR3 (with some help). Certainly an interesting option. Starting the A&StL in SR2 cheaply (solely to lay track to rush the connection and get merged) is intriguing.
I wrote the above before my last game and decided to try it, it worked well, as I pocketed the $200 before SR3. I’d started the A&StL at $40 in SR2, intending to simply take the bonus and then take it over ASAP. The latter part was trickier than I thought, but the basic idea was sound.
I still don’t have a grasp on the takeovers. But giving good stock(s) to yourself and a little $ to others (or giving bad stocks to others and big $$ to yourself) are clearly important.
Arguably the most important things about the takeover game is the train limit changes. Yes, you might lose a company (if you have no train or only phased trains) but the end game seems characterized by non-takeover companies hitting a stock plateau and takeover companies that have a 2nd train really making up the ground they lost (if any) in the takeover. (And takeover companies that don’t have a second train merely suffering the loss of taking someone over).
The lower train limit might impose a fairly significant pause in phase III/IV (and in our last game we didn’t actually get to phase V, although certainly someone can always force it).
The ability of the variable companies to jump in and token out a space is important …. (but remember that the reserved spots are still reserved until fairly late, even if the reserved company has no token). It’s embarrassing to parachute in, try to grab a blocking spot, then get told “Nope” and get blocked in the very spot you were aiming for.
Perhaps after another few months I’ll host a roundtable on this.
Update (10/28) — There is a big ‘bomb’ in the takeover game as to whether Phase V breaks. We had another game w/o it.
On a sem-whim, I bought Dupery (“A game of Solo Deduction”) from Steam. It’s a puzzle game in the style of Werewolf, but this time it’s Noir and Mafia. You have a grid (initially 3×3, but later bigger) of roles. Some innocent, some evil and quite a few are meddlers (innocent, but not necessarily helpful or truthful). You have to untangle the facts and arrest the evil. Arrest too many innocent people before you finish the case (a series of 5-7 puzzles) and you lose.
So far I’ve played 5 hours … the TaoLing has also played.
The good:
Simple but nice graphics, good theming
The puzzles are hard (in fact, for the first several hours I didn’t solve a non-tutorial case) and get harder. Once you’ve solved a few cases at “The Office” then new locations with additional rules are added. (In the Casino you gain and lose chips with each action, which provides clues but also … if you run out of chips you fail. The Docks has hidden people ‘out at sea’ and you have to drive your boat to them to interrogate them, and also watch your fuel). I haven’t unlocked them all
The bad:
The puzzles are dealt out randomly (I think) which means you can get a situation where you know either A or B is lying and just have to bite the bullet and accuse one of them. Given the structure of the game where you need multiple false accusations to fail, this is reasonable. But for some puzzle fans that’s a deal breaker.
There’s only one audio track of a wailing sax. Cool for 10 seconds, annoying after that.
I mean, it’s $10. I’ll probably get another 5-10 hours out of it at least. Reasonable enough.
Part of the lure of duplicate is everyone has the same cards. But that doesn’t make it fair. Today E-W average over 22.7 HCP (to NS’s 17.3).
Thankfully I normally sit East or West.
And not just the HCP but (for the most part) things were on. My partner was complaining “How can I beat the field by finding a squeeze when every finesse is on?”
A typical hand.
West: Axx Axxx Axx Kxx East: KQ JT KJxxx AT8x
With north having QT9 of diamonds in the pocket (and clubs 3-3), slam is cold in NT and/or diamonds, but we were in 3N making 6 (which happened 4 times today, once by N/S!).
I also held the following:
(void) KT9 A9xxx AKQxx (on the advice of the Imp, I took a phantom sac against 5S when partner admitted to having a double fit in minors)
Axx xx Axx AQxxx (3N making only five)
KT8xx AK9x T AKx (4S off one on a 6-1 side suit break and 4-1 trump break)
AKxx Jxx AKx AJx
AKJx Kx Tx KTxxx
Kxx KQT9 Ax QJxx (3N making six when the opening leader lead the 6 from QT86xx of spades and dummy had AJ9x and the opponents did not cash their second ace when in with the first (and got squeezed out of it).
AK AQ9x T AJT9xx (3N making five but 6 Clubs was cold)
AT8xx AQTx — Axxx (4S making)
AKJxx KJ xxx Qx (Opened 1S, partner bid 4H (natural!) and I competed to 5H over RHO’s 5C. Making)
xx KJ9xxx Jxx Kx …. much weaker than my normal hand, but partner overcalled LHO’s 1S with 2 Hearts, so I bid 5H (after RHO made a 3H-cue bid).
AQx AQJ9xxx — QTxx …. Just kidding, that was my partners hand. Mine was stronger, so I opened 2C (Kxx K AKQx AKxxx). Needless to say, we got to 7NT, which has 3S+7H+3D+5C = 18 tricks if everything breaks, but because of a bad heart break only makes 14 tricks.
And a few routine 1N or 1 of a suit opening, just to keep things honest (on the last one, I was in 3N making seven when LHO lead from Kxxx of spades and RHO had ATxx of spades (with Jx in dummy and Qxx in hand) and RHO correctly put in the Ten1, but then I picked up a 5-2 suit with 3-3 break with Qxx onside and proceeded to make seven.
There was noticeable grumbling amongst the N/S pairs…
As compared to that, I was in the unusual position of noticing (eventually) the Imp of the Perverse sitting on my partner’s shoulder. My first clue was a hand I’ve already shown above.
S: AKxx H: Jxx D: AKx C: AJx
I had complained (earlier) that my hands were good but difficult, so finally I got a good, obvious hand. I opened 2NT and when partner transferred to hearts, I accepted. And partner passed. So far so normal.
LHO lead the diamond T and dummy hit with
Dummy — S: J H: T8xx D:8xxxx C: 8xxx
(“I took a position” partner said un-necessarily, as she tabled dummy.)
My Hand again — S: AKxx H: Jxx D: AKx C: AJx
Thankfully I had three hearts! I might have only had two. This hand is a monstrous beast to play at Matchpoints. First of all, the rest of the field will (presumably) be in 2NT. I want to beat them. How much are they going down? No idea! They may only take five tricks, but that lead looks like a stiff and 2NT will probably get a helpful lead. I could try to cash a diamond and (if that works) continue diamonds and see. Or I could “reverse the dummy” and try to ruff two spades and then cash 3 (or perhaps 4) other tricks, but that still looks like death.
In the end I decided to finesse the 8 of hearts and hope for a misplay or diamonds 3-2. But none of those plans would have worked. Down 4.
The second time I picked up another normal looking hand … but normal for a regular game where you average ~10 points a hand.
S: 97xx H: AQ D: 97x C: KTxx
Partner opened 1 Diamond, I responded 1 Spade and partner bid 4 Spades as I had decided to let her have the 18+ point hand for once. With a balanced hand probably capped at 19 I really have no interest in slam, but I pondered it for a few seconds before passing. I needn’t have worried as partner tabled …
S: AT2 H: Kx D: KQJTxxx C: Ax
(This particular partner has done this to me before, her Imp of the Perverse apparently cannot stand making a strong but Not Forcing 3 of a minor rebid with Honor-x-x or better in responders major. As compared to that, this still had a reasonable shot excepting a) I had only four spades, and four terrible ones at that b) I had Kx of hearts instead of nothing or Kxx, meaning we had way too many points in hearts.
Despite that, I might have made it on the heart lead I got, (win in hand, finesse the spade T, win the heart continuation, and now I need for the diamond ace to be on the short side because I cannot play Trump ace and trump (or small trump) first because they can force me with another heart.
Sadly diamonds were 4-0, so I went down one (should have been two).
Obviously it didn’t work on this hand (and RHO might have been able to sniff that out), but as a matter of general principle playing the T is correct. ︎
The Noble Prince contemplated: ego led that one to believe that it could “control” a corporation, when it could not even control itself and attained enlightenment.
Stellar Ventures tries to mix cube rails (like Chicago Express) with 18xx train rusting. There are certainly differences.
In Chicago Express anyone can put any stock up for auction (assuming there are “auction a stock off” actions available this round), which means that as long as a company has stock certificates left, it can be diluted. In Stellar Ventures the President can auction off a share each corporation round, and a single other share will be auction during the boardroom battle. As I wanted to mention in the first thread I listed (before deciding to make this a post), “Bidding too much for a company gives it capital, and the ‘best’ company will naturally attract investors wishing to a) share in the profits or at least b) dilute the profits for the President.”
I’ve still only played S.V. once … and like many of John Bohrer’s games it seems clear to me that groupthink is incredibly important in this game. You do not have the free form ability to weave incentive structures like silk is in his cube rails games; but there will be a raid each turn. It will be important.
It also goes without saying that while “paying too much” is a failure mode; so is “not being willing to pay the going rate.” Sure, you can sit on a stack of cash and miss the round 1 payments. Because the companies need trains spaceships their first payouts are $2 … if you buy nothing and then win the first boardroom battle (presumably for roughly as much as the second richest player has) you can do fine if you also pick up another cheap share. But will you?
S.V. has this weird thing where companies need money (for routes and spaceships) but players can basically pay for their routes (or expand them) during the Investor Round. A president with a broke company (that is not worried about a rust) can choose to put up a share in round 2 to get $10 for the company, at the cost of halving his income for the rest of the game … or perhaps he can pay $5-10 during the prior investor round, get 100% of the profits for that round, and only auction a share during the next board room battle (and, should it not come to that, issue one the following turn).
The other problem with “missing out” is that the companys’ president(s) can earn some Alien Cubes with company money, which can be spent on improving companies (probably the same ones, but you never know) or straight up laundered for profits.
And all of that doesn’t even touch on “Signing the Deal.” I don’t think it is right to sign the deal when you expect to miss (and have your stock tanked to a $1/share valuation at the endgame) … but it provides a burst of cash that might come close to compensating you (particularly if you use it to grab a replacement share or two. And, of course, if you sign the deal, get the burst of cash, and manage to actually meet the goals you are in a great position. But I’ll need more games to think about this.
I was surprised last week to get a shipping notice for Stellar Ventures, and tonight played the first game. This is mostly in the Cube Rails genre, but with 18xx train rusting and some variable powers (that are mostly grabbed in the auction). I bought it figuring I’d get 10-ish plays out of it, and hopefully a few more converts into the 18xx genre.
This definitely looks friendlier than the other games, but I think that look is rank deception. This is a brutal game. Like most cube rails, you might triple (or quadruple) your money if you win. There are only five corporate rounds, and in the first round pretty much every company runs for …. $2. The cube rails games aren’t like modern pinball where you get a million points for putting in a quarter, it’s like old school Factorio where your score is zero … and if you launch a rocket to win the game it’s now one. There are rough breakpoints and sharp elbows. I like that sort of thing, we’ll see if it hold up.
Today I noticed someone else’s group banned Heliocentricity. The TaoLing and I had a phone call with Lou W. (who is named in the credits) and he pointed out that it is powerful, but also “unsubtly powerful,” (as compared to the subtle political powers that I don’t appreciate as much because I have much less experience exploiting them).
My reframing of his position is that a bonus coast (or Space Force’s freighter movement) is like Military Power in Race for the Galaxy … it is strong; but new players perceive it as dominant because its an obvious strategy that is easy to implement.
I cannot dismiss this argument out of hand.
We had a (co-op) game with Explorers without Borders1 and it did prove more useful than expected, letting me refuel an allied rocket two burns away from LEO sometimes lets you dodge weight restrictions (put a bit of fuel in, get +1 thrust for the rad belt), then fuel some more, saving a turn. There are also cases where it helps move your first Bernal faster.
The TaoLing had a game with Cerulean and the reduced FINAO on airbrakes and ISRU upgrade were fine.
LEO Workers Union is kind of counterfeited when playing co-op, but murder/suicide is indeed strong.
Because of Stationfall I keep wanting to type Explorers without Boarders︎
Today’s bridge game had the following: two grand slams (we bid one and the other was a hand that was one of the two sets we didn’t get to play, so didn’t get the chance), a 50/50 small slam bid against us, making (the only table to bid it, sigh) … and then there was the following:
S: KQ H: AKQJT7x D: Kx C: Qx
20 HCP, but is it really? The solid suit is worth more than ten points, but the honors in short suits …. ugh. (To my surprise, KNR counts it as 22! But the DK count is 20-, which strikes me as closer. There’s a strong argument for opening 1 Heart at matchpoints You might miss a game if partner has an ace or as little as the club king, if the diamond ace is right; but if partner can scrounge a 1 Spade or 1 No Trump response you can rebid 4 Hearts and that’s about right on values. Or you can open 2 Clubs.
I asked The Imp’s opinion; he shrugged. (Neither bid is perverse).
But I was in fourth seat. LHO passed and Partner …. preempted 3 Spades.
Can we make slam? I need two aces with partner. I dislike preempts with two aces (except in 3rd seat, sometimes heavy), but this partner has done it from time to time. But if I give partner the black aces slam seems at best 50/50, because we might lose two quick diamond tricks. What if I declared? Six Hearts of Six NT? That might work.
But how to investigate? I can’t just shoot Blackwood. (The Imp disagrees, but it is merely pro forma). This is matchpoints, I’m happy missing a 50/50 miracle slam.
What about 3 No Trump? This guards my diamond king, but we might be open the entire club suit, not to mention that LHO might lead a club to RHO’s Ace, and then a diamond through me ends the hand.
If I had any bid that said “I agree spades, and am slammish” I’d make it. (With some partnerships, 4 Clubs after a preempt is a modified Blackwood called “Weak Man’s Keycard,” but not in this one which would let me find out cheaply). So, resigned to being dummy, I bid 4 Spades which ends the auction.
Care to guess which game(s) or slam(s) make?
The answer
It turns out that the only making games are five of either minor … for the opponents!
———- NORTH S: — H: xxx D: QJT8xx C: KJTx
WEST S: A9765432 H: — D: 9x C: xxx –|– EAST S: KQ H: AKQJT7x D: Kx C: Qx
———- SOUTH S: JT8 H: 962 D: A7x C: A98x
Partner had 8 spades to the ace, void in hearts, 2 small clubs and three small diamonds. With the diamond ace offside, the opponents should have taken the first four tricks. (They did not). But with my RHO having a spade void and my partner having no hearts, I can never get in to cash my hearts
Even then the play is admittedly tricky. South must extract all of West minors while ruffing two spades, then deliberately lose a spade to West, pitching a heart from North. West must lead another Spade, letting South pitch another heart from North while ruffing.
I really liked Bremen (from PG:B/M). Connection costs are simplified (cities share borders, and any city bordering it pays the single connection cost + the city cost). Also the map is a bit smaller … you need fewer cities to trigger stage 2 & end game, and the cities cost a bit less (8/14/20). You also remove the nukes and the 7 power plants.
(I also like the 2nd edition Power Grid Rule that the cheapest plant at the start of each round has a minimum bid of 1).
Always happy to play Power Grid, but this new expansion was excellent. I might buy it, except that I’m not the one who brings Power Grid.
I’ve mentioned my companion, The Imp of the Perverse from time to time. The Imp sometimes cajoles me, trying to replace good judgement with what he considers “fun.” Often the Imp is quiet; but when we’re playing Bridge he is quite chatty. Luckily, my particular Imp listens to Reason. He won’t consider an obviously bad decision fun. But if it isn’t obvious … or he can come up with a plausible argument …
Sometimes it is tough to distinguish The Imp’s blandishments from stylistic differences. For example, should you make a takeout double with a two card minor (assuming you have 4 cards in each major, enough points, etc)? A national champion told me “You need to pass those hands,” but I believe that East Coast (Washington) Style is more case-by-case.
At least, that’s what the Imp said.
One of my regular partners (who, like most people, cannot see the Imp or hear his soothing words) summed it up as “You think too much” and just advised me to bid the hands straight down the middle and let our natural advantages win us our fair share of games. The Imp scoffed.
In The Imp’s defense …. He is definitely not right all the time, but reasonably often and — right or wrong — his advice leads to spectacular stories. He makes me a sometimes difficult partner, but that means he makes me a difficult opponent.
At a two session special club game (Their “Fifth Tuesday of the Month” game), the Imp keeps motioning towards the “breakfast” spread. Homemade cinnamon buns (cooked with bourbon), a birthday cake, donuts, a crumble cake, ginger snaps, a banana pudding. A full table. In our younger days the Imp would gorge himself and talk up each morsel until I succumbed.
Nowadays he’s also carrying some extra weight, so his heart isn’t really in it. I have a few pieces of pineapple and strawberries.
Early on the Imp doesn’t even have whisper much. We start against the director (the strongest player at the club who is not in my three-way-partnership1), who is my RHO. Over her 1 Heart bid I something like
S: AQxx H:xx D: KJ C: Axxxx. The Imp doesn’t need to prompt me at matchpoints. We’ve had this discussion for years. Yes, a double could work out badly. But partner will prioritize spades and if we end up in diamonds the opponents will strive to compete (each assuming we have a real fit). Yes, I would prefer to bid Raptor, but this partner doesn’t play it. So I double, RHO raises to 2 Hearts and it goes all pass. During the player, declarer carefully watches my discards, assuming I started 4=2=3=4 and misses an overtrick. When she comments “I never thought you’d double with that hand,” the Imp pokes me to make sure I noticed the comment.
We move away from the breakfast spread, so now the game has the Imp’s undivided attention.
I pick up S:AQxxx H:QTxx D:8x C:xx and partner opens 1 Diamond. I have an easy 1 Spade bid. Partner rebids 2 Diamonds and the Imp clears his throat. This is another argument we’ve had so often I can hear his words. If he spoke up, he knows it would annoy me. A simple “ahem” is enough. But (for your sake)
Imp — Bid 2 Hearts. It shows 5 spades, 4 hearts. Perfect description. There’s a shot you can get to 2 Spades or 2NT and this is matchpoints. Either contract would outscore two diamonds.
Me (before I was corrupted) — 2 hearts is forcing. I admit it would be perfect if it wasn’t. And while 2 Spades will probably outscore 2 Diamonds (if partner has three), 2NT only outscores if it makes. They’ll know to lead a club its probably devastating. We probably have an 8 card fit in diamonds. Also, What if partner bids 3 Hearts? (If she has 4 hearts but not enough points to reverse) or worse, has three good hearts. Then we’ll be too high. And if partner has good clubs and 14, then she might bid 3 NT.
Me — And 3 Diamonds is strictly worse than 2 Diamonds. All downside, no upside.
Imp — It’s matchpoints, the size of the disasters don’t matter as much as frequency. In any case, fine, pass. Be the dummy. See if I care.
I bid 2 Hearts. Partner considers this only briefly before bidding 4 Hearts. Even the Imp looks surprised, but we’re both eagerly awaiting dummy. RHO leads the ominous diamond six.
It’s not the dummy we expect (6 diamonds, 4 hearts, ~14-15 points), but it might be the dummy we deserve.
Dummy S:x H:Axxxx D:KJT932 C:x
My Hand S:AQxxx H:Qxxx D:84 C:xx
The Imp nods approvingly. Partner might not have an Imp of her own, but at least she recognizes the amazing potential playing strength of her hand. (Not her fault if I don’t have my bid). Some would pass that hand instead of opening! Meanwhile I’ve got problems. I’m off two aces, at least a trump trick, and probably two diamond tricks and a diamond ruff to boot.
Another thing about the Imp — he picks his spots. He’s much louder when the opponents are weak. “Maybe it’s wrong, but they’re weak and two wrongs make it right!” is his mantra. Now he just has his shorthand of “Punish the weak!” as a closing argument. That might have been on my mind when I bid 2 Hearts. Now it’s time to deliver.
I’ve taken my time at trick one (The Imp is quiet … if too many of his bids result in disaster, I’ll stop listening …. for a while). I do an asset survey of spot cards. I have a number of options, and I should probably fly with the king, but there’s just a chance that LHO has lead from Q87 of diamonds. It would be a terrible lead, but I’ve played against this pair before. There’s a reason the Imp’s leering nods in their direction work.
I play the Jack and when RHO produces the queen I follow with the 4. RHO leads a club through. LHO wins the jack and tries to cash a high club. I ruff and cash the heart ace. RHO drops the king. Nice, but JT is still around, and a trick. But at least they won’t be on lead before the crucial point.
“Small diamond”
RHO now grimaces and thinks while the Imp shivers expectantly. When she plays the seven he lets out an ungracious whoop! as my 8 wins and now the hand is under control. Queen of Hearts. Ace of spaces, ruff a spade, ruffing finesse against the diamond ace to set up diamonds. LHO can ruff in whenever, but the diamonds are set up and dummy still has a trump entry to get to the rest of the diamonds.
The Imp pulls out a cigarette and smokes it, languidly, and I admit it. That was good. Perhaps I should have flow the king of diamonds on trick one to really sell the fact that I had a singleton, but a) that inference would probably be lost on RHO and b) I’d feel terrible if it really was a lead from Qxx.
Later on I overbid and we get to 5 diamonds. After cashing two tricks the opponents never even try to cash their two spades, instead giving me an obvious ruff and sluff to let me make. Even the Imp’s eyes grow wide, and he stays silent. That wasn’t even a swindle, just legitimate terrible play.
During Lunch the breakfast tray beckons, but the Imp seems satisfied that I have a bit more carbs from the lunch table than I should.
After lunch I pick up S:QT8xxxx H:QJxx D:– C:Ax and it goes pass-pass to me. We are vulnerable.
This is a hard hand. There’s an argument for any of spades (1-4). But — perhaps shaken by the number of close calls I’ve had so far — I decide to open 2 Spades and the Imp merely shrugs. Anything could be right. I might miss a game (but partner is a passed hand). Hearts might be a better place to play, but Hank’s Rule (“7-4 hands are one suited”) applies. I have a seventh spade (normally a no-no for a weak two bid), but they aren’t great. Being vulnerable I’m more worried about -200.
LHO bids 3 diamonds (unsurprising) and partner bids 3 Spades. RHO thinks for a second and bids 3 No Trump.
Four eyes (mine and the Imp’s) narrow in thought. With a fit, our hand can be evaluated as a 5 loser hand with Losing Trick Count (Really 5.5 as I count Qxx as 2.5 losers, but with a 9 or 10 card, 5). RHO undoubtedly has the Ace of King of spades, but also probably a fitting diamond card to bid 3NT as a passed hand. Partner has no Imp whispering in her ear, so call it 7+ points.
(Hank’s Imp scares even my companion, so I couldn’t assume that if he were across the table from me).
And if none of them are in diamonds ….
I bid 4 Spades. It such an obvious two-way shot. I’ve got good odds of making, and if not maybe 3NT makes (via one spade, six diamonds and AK of hearts or something similar). “You don’t pre-empt and bid again,” is the rule. But the Imp has Zia on his side. And its not like I was bidding 2 Spades as a pre-empt. It was more a tactical decision. And now I have a lot of information.
It goes pass-pass and RHO doubles. LHO leads a top diamond and dummy hits with
Dummy S:Axx H:KTx D:xxxxx C:xx
With my queen of spades behind the KJx, there is nothing to the play. I lose a club, a heart and a spade. +790.
From “Matchpoints” — When presented with the choice between an underbid and an overbid, make the bid that is more likely to get you to the correct trump suit. ︎
Update 10/1 — Updated based on some rules discussions. Updates included inline.
The Person formally known as The TaoLing is back in town for a few months, and had some time off. We’ve previously played High Frontier (nearly a decade ago), so we’ve played a few games of HF4A now, working up from simple “Race To Titan,” then an Altruism or two (so that any rules mistakes would affect us equally) and finally M012 with contracts (and doubled FINAO) from M4, but not augmentations/isobank/exodus. And also crew. As such, it’s time to start the discussion of the crews from the pack.
This is somewhat fraught as many of the crews abilities vary in utility depending on the module. But there does seem to be a vast disparity in any case. These are sorted by color (first) then by name alphabetically. Having such variance isn’t bad (in particular, I might take a weak power when teaching or solitaire, but as the angel said in 2016 — Malcolm is overpowered and needs to be nerfed. I’ll use the FUDGE scale for my ratings (Terrible, Poor, Mediocre, Fair, Good, Great, and Superb, along with ?)
General Thoughts
Thrusts are mostly 11-14, so enough to hit the big Jovian moons … the 14s can land most anywhere even loaded and the 15s can definitely. 14 or 15 is a plus. Less than eleven is a minus.
Most Fuel Consumptions are 8, but they range up to 14 and I think there’s a 7. In general you are only burning once to land on a large site, although in theory you could go 2+ lander burns in some places. I’ll not <X>T/<Y>FC for thrust/fuel consumption.
All have an afterburn cost of 2. The low thrusts might need to afterburn or the might need to afterburn just for a therm.
All robonaut 4s (except The Martian Way is a 3), the missile only are a bit worse due to lack of raygun or buggy bonuses, but that’s pretty minor. (The buggy matters mostly for Mars and other multi-claims). In general the robonaut type isn’t a big deal.
The Actual Crews
BRIN (Green. 11T/14 FC Dirt) — Your radiators have 2 extra rad hard during a belt roll. Back is flip radiators to heavy side. It’s a dirt thruster (nice!), but the 14 cost is … very high, even for crew. Still, it might allow a mid-game site refuel to max and then aerostat (etc). I like the extra rad-hardness, but if you are using your 11 Thrust through the rad belt (with most of the crews) you can substitute a turn for this power. Rating — Poor (but maybe the dirt thruster improves it to Fair).
Heliocentricty (Green 15T/8FC) — After your stack moves, you can activate this thruster to coast. Monstrously good. Get an extra hohmann pivot for free, sometimes you can coast into an aerobraking. The backside immunity to some hazards is also great. Rating — Superb. Along with Space Force (see below) this seems much more powerful than most.
Utopia, Inc (Green, but misprinted yellow. 10T/8FC) — I don’t play with M5, so … no opinion. But low thrust.
Maker’s Guild (Grey. 14T/9FC. Missile 4) — Getting Bernal Profits with just a factory is nice. Being able to ditch two cards for a card as a free action (and skip the auction) is quite nice. Rating — Good.
New Pilgrims (Grey. 12T/9FC. Buggy / Raygun 4) — Being able to Claim Jump (not as a felony) and share can be OK. If you have a play group that makes deals you might even be able to have someone lay a claim you couldn’t just to split the factory. On the flip side exomigrating a specific specialty also seems nice. Rating — Good.
VerisAI (Grey. 15T/9FC. Missile / Raygun 4) — I don’t play with M5, so … no opinion.
AEB (Purple. 11T/8FC) — I don’t normally work politics too much, so being able to Lobby by making a delegate centrist (instead of decommissioning) seems … ok. Being able to start/end anarchy on the flip side might be very powerful, but conditional. No rating. Rating — Poor/??
Jaxa (Purple. 12T/8FC) — Winning a contract automatically at six years seems …. situationally very good but the situation is rare. The flip side of being able to get spaceborn w/o BEO (and flip augmentations) seems also OK. Rating — Fair. Update — This also depends on how many people are playing; with more players it gets more powerful.
Space Force (Purple. 14T/10FC) — Moving as a freighter seems incredible, turning you as a solar sail that can go out (until you get a glory chit).1 And the flip side is higher weight, with glory chit. And the 14T is a nice cherry on top! This seems too powerful, in need of some nerfing (The TaoLing and I discussed a much lower thrust, perhaps 9, lower rad-hardness, or — like a solar sail — decommissioned by aerobraking). Rating — Superb. One other option is that you can’t move as a freighter with a glory chit OR contract….
Baltimore Gun Club (Red. No Thruster! Raygun 4.) — Bonus burn starting at LEO (etc when flipped), great. No crew rocket! Horrible. 2 Mass, also horrible! (Does a bonus burn act like a flyby?). Rating — I’d have to try it, but … Poor? Update — Definitely difficult to operate, but the bonus burn does really matter for the first mission, so I’m going to say that it might be Fair.
Brotherhood of CrytptoBankers (Red.12T/11FC. Missile 4) — I don’t play with M5, so … no opinion but I note the 11 FC is a bit of a slap in the face. And only a missile robonaut!
Explorers w/o Borders (Red. 9T/8FC. Missile/Raygun 4) — The base ability (free cargo transfer of aqua to LEO/Bernal) only seems to matter if you have a Home Bernal (therefore, your bank) AND a thruster at LEO (where you normally couldn’t give it water), which is an edge case you try to avoid. Update — After some discussion, this lets you transfer water to any of the Home Bernal anchor points, which means you can boost through the cycler/rad belt and then load more fuel, which may save you some thrust (and or not return to LEO to refuel for some missions). Also, a Net Thrust of 9 is … bad. It means you have to load balance a few sites that other’s can hit heavy, and can’t even get you the Moon or Mars. The flipped side might be useful if you get isotopes before bernals but i’d have to think about so meh. Rating — PoorFair
Cerulean (White. 15T/9FC. Missile 4) — If you end on an aerobrake or hazard FINAO costs one and gains an FT. Situationally seems quite good (if you are going Saturn early). Refueling as ISRU zero (once you flip) is nice, but it requires a Bernal, which means you might have a factory. Also an Air eater Rating — Fair? Good? I’d need to play with it more
Galahad Group (White 15T/9FC. Missile 4) — Carry any number of glory chits and lobby honor w/o losing a delegate and (flipped) during exomigration your colonists can appear anywhere you have a colony chip. The latter seems strong, but you have to get the chits. Rating — Good?
The Martian Way (White. 14T/7FC. Missile 3) – Immunity to Pad explosions and and -2 to earth rad roles. Also a ‘3’ robonaut instead of the typical ‘4’. The flipped side of producing “C” spectrum at non-C sites is nice … but also counterfeited2 by the hex augmentation (if you are playing with those). Rating — Good.
African Union Space Directorate (Yellow. 12T/9FC. Buggy/Missile 4) — Performing a vote tally (for free?3) and treating your delegates at 2 each seems powerful way to force the law(s) you like into action, and the flip side of treating any/all tied ideologies as laws can be quite good. I do not normally focus on politics … but this seems fine. Rating — Fair, maybe Good.
Leo Workers Union (Yellow, but misprinted Green. 14T/11FC. Raygun/Missile 4) — 2 extra aqua and murder/suicide seems reasonable. Being able to choose first player and hijack even colonized factories seems nice. I suspect you go bernal early for the income, the can ET produce at others factories…. Rating — Fair or Good.
The Sea Peoples (Yellow. 14T/8F. Buggy/Missile 4) — Connections is pretty reasonable, being able to do any contract you have a delegate gives you good flexibility. The flip side of getting rebates on FINAO is nice, particularly if you are playing the M4 Exodus variant, where you can get back ~4 (or even more for the desperation starship FINAO). Rating — Good.
I think there’s a big gap between the bonus move crews (Heliocentricity and Space Force) and everything else, at least if you are playing with contracts. Being able to bid on a contract on Turn one is a big deal … nobody can undercut you … because they can’t fly. They probably are still Great without contracts.
Anyway, this is mostly the discussion of “How good do think these are….” … proposed balance changes are later.
Also — Why is the Trojan Jovian Camp so much farther from Saturn than the Greek Jovian Camp? Both are roughly the same distance from Jupiter, and both are in lagranges (so … stable relative to jupiter) so my naive (earthbound) feelings is that they should be equidistant to a Jupiter flyby…
This was even worse in our last game, because the opening contracts included one to allow suicide, so you could get the glory chit/finish the contract/suicide repeat with zero cards. ︎
TaoLing — “Isn’t is also counterfeiting going to Mars, since you can get your ‘C’ site stuff anywhere?” Me — Nods approvingly. TaoLing — “Also, it’s not a buggy, which you’d definitely want on Mars.” ︎
It’s at the start of the turn, so it seems to not be free, and optional. ︎
I played another game of Merchant of Venus last night, and it has quietly moved up from “Once every few years” to “Two or three times a year is fine, more would probably be fine” on my list. Part of my appreciation might have come from writing an appreciation, and the 5p game I played last night was perhaps a touch too long, but I also liked that there were a variety of strategies I saw used, including the “Buy a freighter” strategy, which is rarely seen, but won.
I have little to add; but my rating is solidly a Suggest.
Ted Lasso — Strong first season; it’s easy to see why it was so hyped. Later seasons are a mixed bag (likely cause — expanding from 10 30-minute episodes to 12 45-ish minute episodes). Part of why this worked is that there is almost nothing “cringe” in the first season … but it started creeping into S2 and S3. (Because of Ted Lasso I subscribed to AppleTV, at least for a bit, and so I’m trying various shows on that to see).
Zodiac — Workmanlike movie that is captures that slice of time. Excellent cast (not just top billing, but full of “Oh, that guy” character actors). At 2:40 it didn’t feel long.
Maybe
The Amateur — A touch too long & by the book, but … competently done. In most thrillers, you can almost alwasy ‘guess the secret surprise bad guy’ by the actor they cast. I appreciated that announced it right away and didn’t leave it as a “twist.”
How to Stay Smart in a Smart World (Book by Gerd Gigerenzer) –I really liked “Risk Savvy,” (his book on decision making) and it actually changed some of my decisions, so this book (on dealing with advances in AI) was an auto-read. I think most of my readers will already know quite a bit in here, but it’s well done. Gigerenzer is … not an AI skeptic, but perhaps a skeptical realist. At 4 years old this book is already dated, but worth skimming.
Schmigadoon — Assuming you like musicals, pretty good. (Modern couple gets isekai’d into a musical world, stuck until they find true love). It helps that each season is super-short, and there were only two seasons (although I would have liked to see the 3rd season, which would have dealt with 80s musicals like Into the Woods, Phantom of the Opera, etc)
Slow Horses — The first season did some rare things; also a fair number of cliches. Later seasons … basically are all “the same things repeated,” within the different “mystery of the season” plot. That being said, the seasons are short enough.
The Universal Baseball Association, Inc. J. Henry Waugh, Prop (Book by Robert Coover) — I tried this after mentioning it (again) in the 20th Century Project on APBA Baseball (etc). It was fine …. definitely a book of a past time, and I could see the dark comedy, etc. But after three weeks I was only through 1/3rd of it and I punted and just read the summary on Wikipedia. Despite not finishing it personally, I thought it was pretty good.
Maybe Not
The Accountant 2 — The first Accountant wasn’t bad … kind of guilty pleasure OK. This was bad. To make matters worse, the crime has basically no financial element (it’s gotten out of the way in a 1 minute dialog) and it’s just a standard action flick except that a) Ben Affleck has no charm (which is played for laughs), b) the center for neuro-divergent children is basically the Bat Cave that can solve any problem. I do like Jon Bernthal, and he’s OK-ish.
Reacher Season 4 — I mean, I’m watching it …. but quality has dropped noticeable. It’s not like it was realistic before, but there weren’t fully-automatic gun battle/car chases mid-season (or falling through broken glass 20-30 feet and then instantly running away). I might actually watch the spinoff, which will likely have to go smaller instead of bigger.
Young Sherlock (Amazon Prime) — A flashy series by Guy Ritchie, but it is not Sherlock Homes (or even Sherlock, which had a fidelity1 this lacks despite the modern setting). Not bad, but … if you don’t want to make a Sherlock Holmes show, don’t include the name.
Nope
Murderbot — From the one episode I watched, the writing made Twilight look like Shakespeare.
I rarely buy new videogames, but I do check them out from time to time. The trailer for Scarlet Deer Inn is charming and tempting (and if you are bored after a few seconds, skip to the 1:20 mark).
All the Astral Codex Ten yearly reader book review contest finalists are worth reading1, but I particularly recommend The Escape Artist, about Walter Rosenberg (later Rudolf Vrba) who escaped from Auschwitz and tried to warn everyone, but was mostly ignored and forgotten, partially because he was not pleasant, but also because people didn’t want to consider it. “The obvious assumption is that surviving Auschwitz left Rudi emotionally damaged. But Gerta, his first wife, says the causality runs the other way: in her telling, Rudi had always been paranoid and combative, and those traits were what got him out alive in the first place.”
The contracts and augmentations do make each game feel different. Getting an income boost lets you take off faster, at the cost of having to go to a place you would normally ignore. An early ability can be game changing. Literally, like being able to ignore budget cuts or having a better rad-hardness. And the augmentations …. getting a colonist who adds a hydration, or is an ISRU1 raygun opens up the board. I haven’t gone “Bernal First” often, but could easily see that to get that first augmentation on the board fast.
Needing four augmentations to promote a GW thruster to a TW thruster is a big deal. Normally when I get the GW thruster it’s promoted in a few turns. (One turn if it’s the D-D type) but in my game it took over 20 turns to line everything up.
Having the first isotope produced double FINAO costs from 4 Aq to 8 Aq is huge. (I’m playing the Exodus.2022 variant). I misunderstood the timing and if I’d played it correctly I would have probably hosed myself out of the game. But this solves some of the midgame issues in M012 where you have so much money it doesn’t matter. Money was tighter much longer.
I’m less enchanted with the Isobank/Starshot … it seems good (possibly even great) in solitaire but might be gamey in multiplayer games. It does put a lot of tension and/or racing to be the person to Establish the IsoBank, which is probably good.
As for the rules … well, it’s a good thing I know the developer.1
High Frontier is still Enthusiastic.
Module 4 is also Enthusiastic. I’ll be doing more solo with M4, and introducing it into the group (when that’s reasonable), but if people want to introduce it in stages, that’s OK (and what I did). Contracts only (or Contracts and Augmentations) is a decent first step.
Standard Consulting Rates applied, but I got the “Friends and Family” discount. ︎