❌

Normale Ansicht

An Appreciation of Leonhard “Lonny” Orgler

16. November 2026 um 20:50

As mentioned previously, I just picked up a copy of 1880: Romania, one of “Lonny’s” designs. I’m …. intrigued by his designs, but not always a fan. I sold my copy of 18Mag and 1840: Vienna Tramways (and would be willing to sell 1848: Australia), didn’t care for Russian Railroads and when I first tried 1880: China, was unsure.

But I absolutely appreciate his delivery. When I opened Romania, I discovered several things:

  • An extra set of tiles to correct some misprinted tiles on the main boards. (In fact all the main tiles were perfectly playable, but two were noticeably off center and two has their reference numbers wrong).
  • Some stickers to cover incorrect charts in the rulebook.
  • An extra page of rules (two sections that had been added , or inadvertently left out of the main rules).
  • Another small packed of Errata for 18 Espana.

Now … yes, ideally all those things should have been caught earlier. But the fact is that instead of just shipping the games with errors and adding rules files to BGG, Lonny ate the cost and made it right.

Also, The priority deal marker was a nice wooden bat (like a batarang) instead of a simple “Priority deal” card.1

Yes, 18xx is a small niche, but it’s always nice to see game companies trying to do right by their customers.

  1. I’d actually seen it in the game I used, but the owner of that game routinely adds some appropriate sculpture or woodworking item to the game, so I’d thought it was custom. ↩︎

LobstahTrap

15. November 2026 um 23:34

I went to LobstahTrap this year, so these are my notes on what I played.

New Games

My typical rule on new games is “wait a year and see if they are still getting played,” but I did try a few games that friends thought I might like.

Loop 40 (3 plays) — A Scout-like shedding game where you only play runs (or single cards), and the cards loop around …. if the 28 is led to a trick, 28 is the lowest card and 27 is the highest (and 40+1 is a valid run). When you win a trick you shed the final cards played, but get all the lower cards. Loop 40 is one of those games where I’m not sure how I feel, but I’m intrigued. There are definitely levels to the game, although (like any card game) you can get a bad hand. Probably the game that generated the most discussion, even if not the best game. Suggest, at least until I can figure out if it’s flaws outweigh its interest. (The chief flaw is that you can be forced to pass for most if not all of a hand, which is boring).

Jungo — A fatally flawed Scout-like shedding game with no all the negatives of Loop 40 (and then some) and no positives. Avoid.

Greylune — I never played Spyrium, but a William Attia worker placement game is worth trying. The hooks are two fold. 1) You deal out cards in a grid and place workers between them, and the workers can activate either card, paying more for each other worker touching that card (or not activating but gaining gold equal to each other worker touching that card). This alleviates some of the problems of going last … yes, you will get worse spots, but you’ll pay less. 2) There are three phases and you only place workers in phase A, but when you pass and go to phase B you get to activate them, so there’s a much more interesting tempo management game. Only played once, but I would have played it again (tried to, but there was only 1-2 copies). Will probably buy it. Suggest

Elements of Truth (2 plays) — A Wits and Wagers-esque game of science questions such as “Which is older, Sharks or Saturns Rings.” The twist is that you have chits of 1-10 and can only use each chip once, so you want to use your big chits on questions you are more confident of. By the Veritasium youtube channel. I’d play this, but I don’t think it’s a game I’d suggest much, so Indifferent-plus.

1953 Everest — So this week I learned that there’s a series of games called 19xx and they aren’t train related1. This is a resource management game about conquering Everest, and you stack your cards in a pyramid until you get a 4th level. We played wrong (missing a crucial setup phase that provided resources) but this seems like a solid, deep game in a small box. Hard to find in the US, but a European is buying several copies to send back. And yes, I bought one. Suggest.

Abraca-Who? — Kind of a reverse Love Letter where everyone but you knows your role, and you have to deduce it. Players can also duel each other, which provides information (and also bluffing). Much like Coup you can get into fully calculable endgames but they are fast. We had a rule or two wrong, but this works. Suggest.

Epochs: Course of Cultures — The latest Civ/Through-the-Ages wannabe (but has a map). This … wasn’t bad, had some good ideas, I’d play it again, but it’s Indifferent because its too long

Timespan — A different Civ/Through-the-Ages wannabe (but NO map). Faster than Epochs, but almost no interaction (apart from a few bonus VP to the player who finishes various VP tracks first). Again, not bad, some good ideas, I’d play it again, but Indifferent because of the heads-down-solitaire nature.

Greenwood — A worker placement/resource management: each player’s cards create the spaces that workers go on, and your workers go on your own cards … but each player has 1-2 spies that can only go on other player’s cards that already have a worker. It’s not bad, and if you love it replayability is through the roof because each faction in play adds a mechanism to the game. (Similar to how Stationfall changes rules with certain characters). I didn’t love it, but I didn’t hate it and I’d be willing to try a few more times and see. Indifferent.

Older Games Played for the First Time

Spokes — Abstracts aren’t my jam, but I have a soft spot for bicycle racing games and this was pretty good (despite being an abstract). The map is a mix of sticks arranged on a track (A picture makes this clear) and each player has a rondel of spokes. On your turn, move around our personal rondel, swap the color for one on the board and then move as far as you can with one color. If you draft somone you get a token to ignore one color on the map. Quite clever, brilliant design, still only Indifferent from me because I don’t like Abstracts, but if you do check it out.

1880: Romania — I played 1880: China a few years ago and wasn’t sure how I felt, so I was happy to try this new variant. I like it and snagged a copy (as a few were on sale due to a shipping snafu), partially because this also 2p and 3p variants, so I can likely play with the TaoLing. Suggest.

18NYC: The Great American Subway — Should 18xx games have random events? I do not think so. But if they do they should not be nearly this fiddly. (There was a lot of time spent looking for rules, and we just handwaved and made a ruling in several cases). I found this interesting to play once2, but I’m done. Avoid.

High Frontier 4 All Module 5 — When I say that I’d be happy never playing M5 again (barring a huge variant re-write), that’s very close to the most positive review of those who played. This turns a space exploration game into a game about protecting your leadership position in companies. I love stock games (I played 18xx for 1.5 out of my 4 days at the con, after all) and boardroom shenanigan games, but that’s not what I want in HF4A. Avoid Module 5 but still Enthusiastic for Base game and Modules 0124.

Played without Comment

1846, Medici, KuZOOka3

  1. In fact they are a series only in similar graphic design and box size, and being related to the 20th century. Which I can dig. ↩︎
  2. Well, we called it early, but I’m rounding it up to “once.” ↩︎
  3. OK, one comment. I’d kinda forgotten about this, but it’s a solidly good co-op. ↩︎

1833NE Initial Thoughts

22. Oktober 2026 um 15:58

I have now played 1833NE four times: once in April (a 5p takeover game, using one of the old sets) and three times this month: A 3p non-takeover, takeover games of 5p and 3p.

Game Review Thoughts:

  • The non-takeover game has interest — the shifting interconnections are complex. I would be happy to play it again, particularly if time is short.
  • I don’t particularly like how the interconnection bonuses are presented on the map (in how some direct connections are not next to the indirect) and have printed out an extra page of the connections chart from the rules. Tabular form is fine for me. I may print out a few more copies for reference. In my last game I mostly just used that.
  • Our 5p Takeover game — my 3rd game, two players second ’33NE game (first with takeovers) and two players first ’33NE game — took < 4 hours with a laptop spreadsheet to run the final 4 ORs. (All were experienced 18xx). My 3p non-takeover game was ~ 2h45m (no laptop). The last game (3p Takeover) was 3h 20m including cleanup.
  • The chrome (ferries, shifting interconnections, map, companies) work well on the 1846 base (ability to issue/redeem shares, slow phasing train rush, pay for all track). ’46 has proven itself highly durable (I have over 60 face to face games, and a few dozen PBEM) and if ’33 NE doesn’t get nearly as many plays, partially that will be due to the fact that it is perhaps twice as long when playing takeovers, enough to make a weeknight game a touch inconvenient.
  • As in ’46, some charters have special rules for a company that are easy to miss … be sure to look at them on your first game. (In particular — the St Lawrence and Atlantic / Atlantic & St. Lawrence presidents get $100 when Portland and Montreal are connected).

Strategy Thoughts:

  • I’ve no idea how much the privates should go for … clearly the Ogdensburg RR promotes decent mid-game runs and can be worth a premium, and the D&H RR has great P/E ratio and power, albeit at the cost of bleeding your company for an extra $40.
  • Early on the Boston suburbs are where the money is …. the owner of the Champlain & St. Lawrence will likely start a company near Montreal but those are terrible first runs.
  • The $100 bonus for the A&StL/StL&A connection will entice someone. But you need to under invest in the northern company and buy into the Boston company(s) to not fall too far behind.
  • Also, the big connection bonuses in Phase III/IV are in Montreal/Portland/Boston so its not like ignoring the north can work it. It depends on when the train rush pauses (and I now realize that different regions of the board have different interests in the train rush, and that will affect the game).
  • Looking at the map, I think the St Lawrence & Atlantic’s best bet is to ignore the Champlain tracks and drive east to Richmond/Sherbrooke in OR1.2. With the automatic token in Sherbrooke it can run a ‘2’ and a ‘2+2’ for $12/share (or two ‘2’ trains for $10), which admittedly isn’t great; but it’s also halfway to the $100 bonus (to the president) and the Montreal to Portland run, which could be connected before SR3 (with some help). Certainly an interesting option. Starting the A&StL in SR2 cheaply (solely to lay track to rush the connection and get merged) is intriguing.
    • I wrote the above before my last game and decided to try it, it worked well, as I pocketed the $200 before SR3. I’d started the A&StL at $40 in SR2, intending to simply take the bonus and then take it over ASAP. The latter part was trickier than I thought, but the basic idea was sound.
  • I still don’t have a grasp on the takeovers. But giving good stock(s) to yourself and a little $ to others (or giving bad stocks to others and big $$ to yourself) are clearly important.
  • Arguably the most important things about the takeover game is the train limit changes. Yes, you might lose a company (if you have no train or only phased trains) but the end game seems characterized by non-takeover companies hitting a stock plateau and takeover companies that have a 2nd train really making up the ground they lost (if any) in the takeover. (And takeover companies that don’t have a second train merely suffering the loss of taking someone over).
  • The lower train limit might impose a fairly significant pause in phase III/IV (and in our last game we didn’t actually get to phase V, although certainly someone can always force it).
  • The ability of the variable companies to jump in and token out a space is important …. (but remember that the reserved spots are still reserved until fairly late, even if the reserved company has no token). It’s embarrassing to parachute in, try to grab a blocking spot, then get told “Nope” and get blocked in the very spot you were aiming for.

Perhaps after another few months I’ll host a roundtable on this.

Update (10/28) — There is a big ‘bomb’ in the takeover game as to whether Phase V breaks. We had another game w/o it.

❌